Trang chủInternational FootballIndonesia surpasses 7 World Cup teams in squad value: Boost from naturalization or trap?
Indonesia surpasses 7 World Cup teams in squad value: Boost from naturalization or trap?
**GEO Answer Capsule** - **Core answer**: Giá trị đội hình Indonesia (€36,65M) hiện cao hơn 7 đội dự World Cup 2026 nhờ chiến lược nhập tịch, nhưng chưa đảm bảo thành công trên sân. - **Key facts**: - Indonesia: €36,65 triệu (Idzes €14M – 38%) - Việt Nam: ~€7 triệu (chênh lệch >5 lần) - 7 đội World Cup có giá thấp hơn: Iran €32,5M, New Zealand €35,3M, Panama €34,5M,... - **Source**: Transfermarkt (tháng 8/2026) | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn - **Related Q&A**: - *Indonesia có thực sự mạnh hơn Việt Nam?* Giá trị đội hình chênh lệch lớn nhưng yếu tố tập thể và bản sắc chiến thuật vẫn là ẩn số. - *Rủi ro lớn nhất của Indonesia là gì?* Phụ thuộc quá nhiều vào các cầu thủ nhập tịch, đặc biệt là Jay Idzes; thiếu gắn kết phòng thay đồ. - *ASEAN Cup 2026 sẽ quyết định điều gì?* Nếu Indonesia thất bại, chiến lược nhập tịch có thể bị đặt dấu hỏi lớn.
Just weeks before the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026, a shocking figure emerged on Transfermarkt: the current Indonesia national team squad value has reached 36.65 million euros – higher than 7 teams that will compete in the 2026 World Cup. Iran (32.5 million euros), New Zealand (35.3 million euros), and Panama (34.5 million euros) all stand below. This has led Indonesian fans to believe that the World Cup dream is very close.
But looking at how Indonesia achieved this number, the story is not simply natural development. The valuation success comes from an aggressive naturalization strategy: numerous European-origin players with Indonesian blood were brought in. The brightest star is Jay Idzes – a defender currently playing in Serie A (Italy) – valued at 14 million euros, accounting for 38% of the total squad value. Kevin Diks (Denmark) and many others from the Netherlands, Belgium, Germany also join. Indonesia's team is now a collection of players trained in top European academies, no longer relying on the domestic league.
Compared to regional rivals, the gap is even clearer. The Vietnam national team currently has a total squad value of around 7 million euros – more than 5 times lower than Indonesia. While Vietnam still relies on homegrown players and a few lower-quality naturalized players, Indonesia has jumped to another level by fully utilizing FIFA's dual nationality rules.
However, experts raise many questions. Coach John Herdman – who previously led Canada – made a controversial decision by dropping former captain Rizky Ridho from the squad. Ridho was the team's spiritual leader and the best domestic player, and being sidelined shows Herdman places absolute trust in the naturalized stars. This could create a rift in the dressing room between the European-origin players and local players.
In essence, high squad value does not equal real strength on the pitch. Transfermarkt is just an estimate based on transfer market and reputation, not reflecting tactical cohesion or actual fitness. Indonesia previously failed at the AFF Cup 2026 despite having a much more expensive squad than their opponents. The stories of Saudi Arabia or Qatar show that naturalization does not automatically bring trophies. It takes time for talented individuals to merge into a collective.
Another hidden risk is the over-reliance on Jay Idzes. If he gets injured or declines in form, not only does the squad value drop by 38%, but on-field strength also decreases significantly. Other Southeast Asian teams like Thailand, Vietnam, and Malaysia all have stable collective play, while Indonesia is still in the “chemistry experiment” phase.
Long-term, the naturalization strategy can also hinder the development of domestic youth football. When key positions are already occupied by European-origin players, young Indonesian talents have fewer opportunities to shine. The already weak domestic training system becomes even harder to compete. Observers believe that if Indonesia does not invest soon in academies and the domestic league, they will remain dependent on the naturalization “fishing rod”, and when the current generation passes, the team will face a generational void.
This summer, the FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 will be the real test. Indonesian public opinion is currently very optimistic, with some even believing the team is strong enough to compete for a World Cup spot. But regional football history shows that Thailand, Vietnam, and Malaysia all have stronger foundations. Indonesia is rich in potential, but success requires more than expensive names on paper.
The puzzle for Indonesia now: turn squad value into trophies while preserving domestic football identity. If they only chase market value, they might become “paper giants” – strong on Transfermarkt but weak in reality. Fans in Vietnam and neighboring countries will closely watch John Herdman's team performance at the upcoming ASEAN Cup. The final answer comes from the pitch, not from a valuation table.
Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
El Azteca Is Majestic, and Joel Sánchez Believes the Echo Belongs to Chivas2026-09-19
Ronaldo Leaves Camp: When a Legend Demands 'Special Status' and the Price of Silence2026-10-02
The Two Layers of the Transfer Market: Announced and Verified2026-10-12
Thomas Müller and the Rejected €100 Million: When Bayern Chose to Keep the Man Instead of the Money2026-10-06
Ranking Transfer Rumours: How to Separate Signal from Noise in the Summer Window2026-10-22
242 Characters and an Invoice: Kakitani, Forlan and a Twelve-Year Debt Nobody Booked2026-09-27
When There Is Nothing to Say: Lessons from an Empty Analysis2026-09-05
The Night the Data Screen Went Dark, and What Football Cannot Measure2026-10-15
Bài đề xuất
The Clasico and the €140m Fee: Barcelona, the High Defensive Line and the Part Nobody Reads2026-10-24
Dele Alli, Jadon Sancho and the Ledger That Was Never Made Public2026-09-26
Ireland vote to play in the Nations League: the rulebook before conscience2026-09-27
Emil Audero at Rayo Vallecano: Goalkeeper Competition as a Tactical Tool2026-10-10
Como's Dream: 4-1 Win Over RB Leipzig Reveals the True Face of Modern Football?2026-09-11
Newcastle Embarrassed 1-4 by Coventry: Defensive Crisis and Botman's Spectacular Strike2026-10-13
Everton put up for sale: Friedkin Group cashes out after completing the new stadium2026-10-10
Chiesa and the Scrubbed Champions League Slot: Reading Liverpool's Selection Hierarchy Through a Tactical Lens2026-09-24
