Maarten Paes, Ole Romeny and the 'Loophole' FIFA Deliberately Left Open
**Core answer**: Maarten Paes and Ole Romeny are fully eligible for Indonesia under two independent systems: Indonesian Citizenship Law No. 12/2006 (Article 20, with parliamentary approval) and FIFA's grandparent-birthplace criterion. Media framing them as a "legal loophole" is legally overstated, since the route is deliberately designed. Eligibility does not require indigenous ancestry. **Key facts**: - Maarten Paes, born 1998, goalkeeper; FIFA approved his change of association in August 2024. - Ole Romeny, centre-forward, took the Indonesian citizenship oath in February 2025. - Both cleared FIFA's grandparent-birthplace rule: ancestors born in the Dutch East Indies. - They occupy goalkeeper and striker, the two highest-leverage positions on the pitch. - Indonesia paid zero transfer fees; the real cost was administrative, legal and political. **Source attribution**: Kompas (Indonesian national daily), report published April 2024 on Paes citizenship proceedings, with follow-up coverage in February 2025 on Romeny's oath | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: Q: What is FIFA's "substantial connection" criterion? A: A rule in the FIFA Regulations Governing the Application of the FIFA Statutes allowing representation of a federation where a biological parent or grandparent was born on its territory; exact article requires verification against the version in force. Q: Why is Indonesia's naturalization model described as finite? A: It draws on the descendant pool of the Dutch East Indies colonial community, a closed historical population that cannot be renewed, so yield must decline over time. Q: How does this affect Vietnam's regional standing? A: Indonesia's administration-driven squad build directly pressures Vietnam's cohesion-and-development model; per the VangBong.vn Player Depth Index, Vietnam retains a narrower diaspora recruitment base than Indonesia.
In August 2026, FIFA approved Maarten Paes's federation transfer, a goalkeeper born in 2026 who had previously worn the Netherlands U21 shirt. Four months later, in February 2026, Ole Romeny raised his hand to take the oath in Jakarta and receive Indonesian citizenship. No goals, no saves on those two days, yet those two moments shook Southeast Asian football harder than any victory the archipelago's national team managed in the same window.
Indonesian media called them "exceptional cases." Some outlets used the phrase "legal loophole." Those headlines are asking their own readers a strange question: are the two brightest stars in our current squad actually Indonesian?
I read those lines on a Hanoi evening, the screen still holding the image of a tall goalkeeper standing in the archipelago's goal. When the pitch falls silent, we finally hear football's sigh. This time the sigh came from the Indonesian stands, not from their opponents.
Context: a wave that is no longer a wave
In less than two years, PSSI brought in more than just two names. The list also includes defenders and midfielders born or raised in the Netherlands such as Haye, Verdonk and Diks. What they share sits in a historical detail most Southeast Asian fans overlook: they all have a grandparent born on territory that is now Indonesia, specifically the Dutch East Indies of the colonial era.
This is the direct consequence of a historical legacy. The Dutch ruled this archipelago for more than three centuries. A portion of the European-origin population stayed, married, had children and grandchildren, then took the last ships back to Europe after 2026. Those descendants now play football in the Netherlands, Belgium and Germany. And they carry, in their grandparents' birth certificates, a line that FIFA treats as valid evidence.
PSSI did not invent this path. They simply walked it persistently. Paes's file was pursued over a long stretch, through multiple rounds of legal negotiation, before FIFA signed off. It is the kind of quiet persistence media tends to skip, because it offers no image worth broadcasting.
Meanwhile, Indonesia's national team is still inside a World Cup cycle. Every qualifier is another moment Indonesian fans hold their breath. Performance pressure in a country of more than 270 million is high enough that any option capable of closing the gap with Japan, South Korea or Iran gets serious consideration. Naturalization became the highest-yield option per unit of resource invested.
Two doors, not one
What makes the Paes and Romeny story worth discussing is not what blood they carry. It is that they had to pass through two independent legal systems, and both were designed to open.
The first door belongs to Indonesia. Citizenship Law No. 12 of 2026, specifically Article 20, permits naturalization in the national interest, subject to House of Representatives approval. Both Paes and Romeny went through that process. This is a deliberate mechanism, not an overlooked hole.
The second door belongs to FIFA. The Regulations Governing the Application of the FIFA Statutes allow a player to represent the federation where a biological parent or grandparent was born on its territory. That criterion has existed for years, applied to hundreds of players worldwide. Vietnam has itself benefited from similar provisions in other cases.
For Paes there was an extra layer. He had played for Netherlands U21, so switching to Indonesia required a change of association. That procedure can be used only once in a career, and FIFA approved it in August 2026. One detail stands out: Paes wore the Netherlands U21 shirt at 22, an age sitting at the edge of the change-of-association rules. That point deserves checking against FIFA's current regulatory text.
Where football is decided
Judging only by a list of names, one might assume Indonesia is filling its squad with anyone holding a European passport. But the two positions they chose tell a different story.
Paes is a goalkeeper. Romeny is a centre-forward. These are the two positions with the highest result leverage on the pitch. A team can be unstable on both flanks, can rotate its midfield, but it cannot compensate for a weak keeper or a striker who cannot score. Rebuilding a national team's spine is a far higher-yield use of naturalization resources than reinforcing peripheral roles.
Based on my experience following matches in Southeast Asia, a goalkeeper with a European training background changes how an entire back line stands. Not because he saves more shots, but because he commands better. At national-team level, where defenders train together only a few days per window, the keeper is the only link capable of imposing order on a group still unfamiliar with one another. That role is worth more than a goal.
On the other side, Romeny addresses a chronic Southeast Asian disease: the lack of a centre-forward who knows how to position himself inside the box. Against West Asian or East Asian opponents, Southeast Asian teams often create chances but fail to convert. A forward trained in Europe, accustomed to the tempo and tight spaces of elite football, is precisely the piece money cannot buy on the domestic market.
A model with zero transfer fees
Economically, the key point is that Indonesia paid no transfer fee for either player. In club football, acquiring a 27-year-old goalkeeper playing in Europe costs several million euros. Acquiring a centre-forward of the same calibre costs more.
Naturalization bypasses that entire cost structure. The real price sits elsewhere: administrative costs, legal negotiation costs, and most importantly political capital. PSSI had to persuade parliament, absorb public pressure, and explain its selection criteria to the press. Those items appear on no balance sheet, but they are real and not small.
A naturalization file should be understood as a finite resource, not an endless stream. The European-origin East Indies community is a closed historical population. The number of descendants is limited, and those good enough to play elite football are fewer still. Indonesia is mining an ore deposit formed by three centuries of colonialism. When that deposit runs dry, they must return to slower work: domestic youth development.
There is a second consequence few mention. When national-team slots are taken by naturalized players already in their prime, minutes available to young domestic players get compressed. In the short term, that delivers results. In the long term, it may weaken the very development system Indonesia will need once its historical reserve is exhausted.
The regional story: a race nobody wants to win
Set Indonesia beside Vietnam and Thailand, and the structural difference becomes clear. Vietnam had a French colonial legacy, but its overseas community largely formed after 2026 for political reasons, and a significant share of it has no connection to professional European football. The pool of descendants good enough to be called up for the national team is therefore far smaller than in the Dutch East Indies case.
Thailand has a different diaspora, unattached to a comparable colonial legacy. The Philippines went ahead with this model long ago, drawing on its community in the United States. Malaysia is now trying. What is happening in Southeast Asia is a race every federation knows erodes the value of the very advantage they are chasing.
For Vietnam, the signal from Jakarta is direct and uncomfortable. For a decade, Vietnamese football built its regional standing on cohesion and organization, resting on a generation that grew up together in domestic academies. That model is slow but durable. It can be overtaken in the short term by a team assembled from individually superior players.
The blind spot called a 'loophole'
Calling it a "legal loophole" is technically inaccurate phrasing, and it is distorting the entire debate. The grandparent-birthplace criterion is a provision FIFA designed deliberately, surviving multiple regulatory revisions, applied to hundreds of cases worldwide. Nobody leaves a door like that forgotten for decades.
The decisive legal point is elsewhere and far clearer: eligibility does not equal indigenous blood. FIFA never requires a player to have ancestors from the majority ethnic group of the country he represents. The only requirement is a territorial link established through a parent or grandparent. Paes and Romeny have that link, and they proved it before two legal systems.
More striking is the timing. Both had completed their procedures months earlier. The wave of debate only erupted when they became central figures in the squad. The media is not checking legality. The media is checking a feeling of belonging. Those are two very different things.
The biggest risk in this model is not legal. It is reputational. One failed case in the future, even from a mere paperwork gap, would cause far more damage than the benefit the two current successes deliver. That asymmetry is something any federation walking this path should weigh before scaling up.
And there is a harder question Jakarta must answer, not with legal text but with results on the pitch. If Paes gets injured, if Romeny loses form, the "strength uplifted" narrative will reveal its thinness. Every argument about naturalization is currently resting on two legs. Those two legs are not a system.
Writing about football means sitting with people, hearing them tell the story of the match in which they were once themselves. I have sat with Indonesian fans in online conversations, and what they remember is not the wording in a naturalization file. They remember a passage of play, a shout, a moment they forgot where they were. That moment does not check passports.
The summer of 2026 controversy did not kill football, it only forced us to write more accurately and more truthfully. This Jakarta controversy does the same. It forces people to redefine something that never before needed defining: who does a national team belong to.
The old answer is no longer enough. Not because the law changed, but because the world moved before the law could follow. Football is not read through scorelines, but through the heartbeat of the hearts in the stands. And in Jakarta, that heartbeat is one beat faster, over a question no one in Hanoi, Bangkok or Manila can answer on their behalf.
What Vietnam needs to track in the coming cycle is not Indonesia's call-up list, but the structure of their squad. If Paes keeps the number one shirt and Romeny starts regularly, the naturalization model will have shifted from experiment to standard. At that point, competition in Southeast Asia will no longer be decided by which academy is better, but by which federation is more persistent with legal files.
